CHAT_OUTPUT_BEGIN
COMMAND_ID=SUPPORT-260924-INFRA-MAIL-FORUM-INBOUND-DEFERRED-HANDOFF-003R1
STATUS=OK
RC=0
HOST=pve01
MODE=read-only
COMPONENT=infra-mail-forum-inbound-deferred-handoff
REFERENCE_REGISTER_CHECK=OK
REFERENCE_SHA256=5a3d8e5154c41cb582a4e0aca68090be1f0138918bf82131a948df326f9d8d66
ERROR_REGISTER_CHECK=OK
ERROR_REGISTER_SHA256=3b09a553ec0f527ed3afeed4753f52a74ee3036045bbfb3c685e9f8af4ba7ba0
COMMAND_SHA256=e0cad2d0fc63469ad0864a3404083c15d67e0a791ffb96a6a7545b52503b0e89
DUPLICATE_FAILED_COMMAND_BLOCKED=false
EXECUTION_STARTED=true
CHANGE_DECLARED=false
RESULT_CONTRACT_VALID=true
RESULT_CONTRACT_STATUS=NOT_APPLICABLE
RESULT_CONTRACT_ERROR=NONE
COMMAND_RC=0
CHANGES_MADE=false
ROLLBACK_STARTED=false
ROLLBACK_RESTORED=null
MUTATION_OUTCOME=NO_MUTATION
SANITIZED=yes
SECRETS_INCLUDED=no
PRIVATE_ADDRESSES_INCLUDED=no
RAW_EVIDENCE_SHA256=daf88cba05ffda510eb8d05dccf6e480cbc83f60240f3f30017b11b101267d57
SANITIZED_OUTPUT_SHA256=daf88cba05ffda510eb8d05dccf6e480cbc83f60240f3f30017b11b101267d57
OUTPUT_BEGIN
CID=SUPPORT-260924-INFRA-MAIL-FORUM-INBOUND-DEFERRED-HANDOFF-003R1
MODE=read-only
COMPONENT=infra-mail-forum-inbound-deferred-handoff
MUTATION_BOUNDARY=NONE;DOCUMENTATION_ONLY;NO_MAIL_SEND;NO_DNS_MUTATION;NO_DB_WRITE;NO_SERVICE_CHANGE;NO_VM_CONFIG;NO_CLOUD;NO_MAILBOX_CREATE;NO_SMTP_AUTH
EXECUTION_STARTED=true
CHANGES_MADE=false
ROLLBACK_STARTED=false
ROLLBACK_RESTORED=null
REFERENCE_SHA256=5a3d8e5154c41cb582a4e0aca68090be1f0138918bf82131a948df326f9d8d66
ERROR_REGISTER_SHA256=3b09a553ec0f527ed3afeed4753f52a74ee3036045bbfb3c685e9f8af4ba7ba0
RUNNER_SHA256=b248a4c32c9cc64e5747e7dce6c7fc0a23f5124a77c71ce72e27a81aceae9d2d
DEFERRED_HANDOFF_VERSION=3
DEFERRED_HANDOFF_DATE=2026-09-24
DEFERRED_TOPIC=FORUM_AND_DOMAIN_MAIL_INBOUND_OUTBOUND_ARCHITECTURE
USER_DECISION=DEFER_IMPLEMENTATION_DO_LATER
CURRENT_ACTION=RECORD_FINDINGS_ONLY
LOCAL_SPENT_CIDS=SUPPORT-260924-INFRA-MAIL-FORUM-INBOUND-DEFERRED-HANDOFF-001R1;SUPPORT-260924-INFRA-MAIL-FORUM-INBOUND-DEFERRED-HANDOFF-002R1;DO_NOT_REUSE
PREVIOUS_002_EXACT_GITEA=404
PREVIOUS_002_CARRIER_RCA=INVALID_POWERSHELL_BASE64_DECODE_QUOTING_IN_FROZEN_CMD;LOCAL_EXIT_BEFORE_AUTH_PROBE_ON_DECODE_FAILURE;NO_SERVER_SIDE_MAIL_DNS_DB_SERVICE_VM_OR_CLOUD_MUTATION_POSSIBLE_FROM_THAT_FAILURE_PATH

=== CURRENT EXACT GITEA ANCHORS ===
ANCHOR_1=FORUM-260924-EXPAND-8FORUM-ALERTS4A27R1;STATUS=FAIL;CHANGES_MADE=true;ROLLBACK_STARTED=true;ROLLBACK_RESTORED=true
ANCHOR_2=FORUM-260924-RCA-PVEPRO-NEWFI-AUDIT6C42R1;STATUS=OK;MODE=read-only
ANCHOR_3=FORUM-260923-FINAL-VERIFY4C8FR1;STATUS=OK;MODE=read-only
ANCHOR_4=SUPPORT-260918-INFRA-MAIL-POSTBOX-FINAL-7OF7-CANARY-EVENT-RECONCILE-PRESEND-PROVEN-514R2R3;STATUS=OK
ANCHOR_5=SUPPORT-260916-INFRA-MAIL-XENFORO-FLEET-POSTBOX-FINAL-CUTOVER-CANARY-UMASKFIX-421R1;STATUS=OK
ANCHOR_6=SUPPORT-260923-PVEPRO-MAIL-CHECKPOINT13-FINALIZE-914R1;STATUS=OK

=== FORUM FLEET CURRENT SCOPE ===
FORUM_TOTAL_CURRENT=8
VM160_FORUMS=codevipe.ru,dsmods.ru,gamevipe.ru,hkmods.ru,kingofwolk.ru,zakrutim.ru
VM210_FORUM=newfi.ru
VM100_FORUM=pvepro.ru
VM160_LAST_FINAL_VERIFY=PASS_FORUM_FINAL_VERIFY
PVEPRO_NEWFI_READONLY_AUDIT=PASS_PVEPRO_NEWFI_AUDIT
LATEST_8FORUM_ALERT_EXPANSION=FAILED_AND_FULLY_ROLLED_BACK
LATEST_8FORUM_FAILURE_SCOPE=PVEPRO_VM100_CANARY_SEND
LATEST_8FORUM_FAILURE_CODE=SMTP_RC_65_SERVER_553_SENDER_ADDRESS_REJECTED_USER_NOT_FOUND
LATEST_8FORUM_ROLLBACK_PROVEN=true

=== OUTBOUND MAIL CURRENT STATE ===
OUTBOUND_GENERAL_MODEL=XENFORO_SENDMAIL_TO_MSMTP_THEN_PROVIDER
VM160_SENDMAIL_TARGET=/usr/bin/msmtp
VM210_SENDMAIL_TARGET=/usr/bin/msmtp
VM100_SENDMAIL_TARGET=/usr/bin/msmtp
POSTBOX_PROVEN_DOMAINS=codevipe.ru,dsmods.ru,gamevipe.ru,hkmods.ru,kingofwolk.ru,zakrutim.ru,newfi.ru
POSTBOX_7OF7_IDENTITIES_VERIFIED=true
POSTBOX_7OF7_DKIM_SUCCESS=true
POSTBOX_7OF7_SEND_SUCCESS=true
POSTBOX_7OF7_SEND_DELIVERY_EVENTS_PROVEN=true
POSTBOX_CONFIGURATION_SET=xenforo-feedback-v1
XENFORO_FEEDBACK_AUTO_MUTATIONS_ENABLED=false
PVEPRO_MSMTP_RUNTIME_PRESENT=true
PVEPRO_PREVIOUS_MAIL_CHECKPOINT_SMOKE=PROVEN_BY_914
PVEPRO_LATEST_ALERT_CANARY=FAIL_553_SENDER_IDENTITY_NOT_ACCEPTED
PVEPRO_OUTBOUND_CLASSIFICATION=DO_NOT_ASSUME_ALL_CURRENT_FROM_IDENTITIES_ARE_ACCEPTED;READ_ONLY_REAUDIT_REQUIRED_BEFORE_NEXT_SEND_OR_CHANGE
OUTBOUND_DECISION=DO_NOT_REBUILD_PROVEN_7DOMAIN_POSTBOX_OUTBOUND_DURING_FUTURE_INBOUND_WORK

=== PUBLIC DNS SNAPSHOT OBSERVED DURING 2026-09-24 CHAT ===
DNS_SNAPSHOT_REVERIFY_REQUIRED_BEFORE_ANY_FUTURE_MUTATION=true
NO_MX_OBSERVED=codevipe.ru,dsmods.ru,gamevipe.ru,hkmods.ru,kingofwolk.ru,zakrutim.ru,newfi.ru
PVEPRO_MX_OBSERVED=0_DOT_NULL_MX_EXPLICIT_NO_INBOUND_MAIL
FORUM_APEX_A_OBSERVED=95.84.154.183
MAIL_PVEPRO_A_OBSERVED=185.139.214.215
FORUM_SPF_OBSERVED=v=spf1_-all
PVEPRO_SPF_OBSERVED=v=spf1_include:spf.postbox.yandexcloud.net_-all
FORUM_DMARC_OBSERVED=reject_POLICY_PRESENT_ON_SEVEN_FORUM_DOMAINS
PVEPRO_DMARC_OBSERVED=p=none;adkim=s;aspf=s
INBOUND_CLASSIFICATION=NO_NORMAL_INBOUND_MAIL_PATH_PROVEN_FOR_SEVEN_FORUM_DOMAINS;PVEPRO_EXPLICITLY_NULL_MX

=== IMPORTANT INTERPRETATION ===
OUTBOUND_AND_INBOUND_ARE_SEPARATE=true
WORKING_XENFORO_OUTBOUND_DOES_NOT_IMPLY_DOMAIN_MAILBOX_RECEIVE_WORKS=true
POSTBOX_USED_FOR_OUTBOUND_AND_FEEDBACK_EVENTS_NOT_PROVEN_AS_GENERAL_INBOUND_MAILBOX_SERVICE=true
MAIL_PVEPRO_EXISTENCE_DOES_NOT_PROVE_FORUM_DOMAINS_ARE_ACCEPTED_AS_INBOUND_MAIL_DOMAINS=true
CURRENT_INBOUND_USER_ADDRESSES_SUPPORT_ADMIN_POSTMASTER_ABUSE=NOT_PROVEN_CONFIGURED
CURRENT_REPLY_TO_BEHAVIOR=REQUIRES_FUTURE_PER_SITE_AUDIT
PVEPRO_553_IS_OUTBOUND_SENDER_IDENTITY_PROBLEM_NOT_PROOF_OF_INBOUND_MAILBOX_CONFIGURATION

=== FUTURE TARGET ARCHITECTURE TO EVALUATE ===
PREFERRED_DIRECTION=KEEP_PROVEN_XENFORO_OUTBOUND_ON_POSTBOX_AND_BUILD_SEPARATE_CENTRAL_INBOUND_PATH
CANDIDATE_INBOUND_REUSE=EXISTING_MAIL_PVEPRO_MAILCOW_IF_READ_ONLY_AUDIT_PROVES_HEALTH_AND_SUITABILITY
CANDIDATE_ALIASES=support@DOMAIN,admin@DOMAIN,postmaster@DOMAIN,abuse@DOMAIN
NOREPLY_POLICY=ALLOW_AS_SENDER_IDENTITY_WITHOUT_REQUIRING_HUMAN_MAILBOX
REPLY_TO_DIRECTION=CONSIDER_support@DOMAIN_FOR_HUMAN_REPLIES_AFTER_INBOUND_EXISTS

=== FUTURE WORK ORDER ===
FUTURE_GATE_1=READ_ONLY_AUDIT_MAIL_PVEPRO_MAILCOW_SMTP25_CURRENT_MAILBOX_DOMAINS_ALIASES_ROUTING_AND_HEALTH
FUTURE_GATE_2=READ_ONLY_AUDIT_CURRENT_CLOUDFLARE_MX_SPF_DKIM_DMARC_FOR_ALL_EIGHT_FORUM_DOMAINS
FUTURE_GATE_3=READ_ONLY_AUDIT_XENFORO_defaultEmailAddress_contactEmailAddress_bounceEmailAddress_unsubscribeEmailAddress_ReplyTo_PER_SITE
FUTURE_GATE_4=READ_ONLY_RCA_PVEPRO_CURRENT_MSMTP_ACCOUNT_ALLOWED_SENDER_IDENTITY_VS_XENFORO_FROM_OPTION_WITHOUT_SENDING_MAIL
FUTURE_GATE_5=VERIFY_ONE_REAL_POSTBOX_MESSAGE_HEADERS_RETURN_PATH_AUTHENTICATION_RESULTS_SPF_DOMAIN_DKIM_D_BEFORE_SPF_CHANGE
FUTURE_GATE_6=DECIDE_REUSE_MAILCOW_VS_SIMPLE_FORWARDING_OR_OTHER_INBOUND_PROVIDER
FUTURE_GATE_7=ONLY_AFTER_DESIGN_APPROVAL_PLAN_BOUNDED_DNS_AND_MAIL_DOMAIN_CHANGES_WITH_ROLLBACK
FUTURE_GATE_8=AFTER_INBOUND_ACCEPTANCE_OPTIONALLY_REVISIT_XENFORO_BOUNCE_APP_ACTION_BRIDGE_POLICY

=== SPF NOTE ===
SPF_SEVEN_FORUM_DOMAINS_CURRENT_CHAT_OBSERVATION=v=spf1_-all
SPF_RISK_NOTE=POSTBOX_OUTBOUND_MAY_PASS_DMARC_VIA_DKIM_WHILE_SPF_ALIGNMENT_OR_AUTHORIZATION_REQUIRES_EXACT_HEADER_VERIFICATION
SPF_FUTURE_CANDIDATE=include:spf.postbox.yandexcloud.net
SPF_RULE=DO_NOT_CHANGE_BLINDLY;VERIFY_REAL_MESSAGE_AND_PROVIDER_REQUIREMENTS_FIRST;KEEP_EXACTLY_ONE_SPF_RECORD

=== SAFETY / DO NOT DO NOW ===
DEFER_ALL_IMPLEMENTATION=true
NO_DNS_CHANGE_NOW=true
NO_MX_CHANGE_NOW=true
NO_SPF_CHANGE_NOW=true
NO_DMARC_CHANGE_NOW=true
NO_MAILCOW_CHANGE_NOW=true
NO_XENFORO_MAIL_OPTION_CHANGE_NOW=true
NO_MAILBOX_OR_ALIAS_CREATE_NOW=true
NO_TEST_EMAIL_SEND_NOW=true
NO_SMTP_AUTH_TEST_NOW=true
NO_SERVICE_RESTART_NOW=true
NO_CLOUD_MUTATION_NOW=true

FAILURE=NONE
DECISION=PASS_DEFERRED_MAIL_FINDINGS_RECORDED
NEXT_GATE=NONE_UNTIL_USER_RESUMES_MAIL_INBOUND_PROJECT
TASK_RESULT=DEFERRED_MAIL_INBOUND_OUTBOUND_HANDOFF_RECORDED
HOMELAB_RESULT_CONTRACT={"version":1,"command_id":"SUPPORT-260924-INFRA-MAIL-FORUM-INBOUND-DEFERRED-HANDOFF-003R1","status":"OK","changes_made":false,"rollback_started":false,"rollback_restored":null}

OUTPUT_END
CHAT_OUTPUT_END